.
Feedback

Supreme Court Upholds Health Care Law

The Supreme Court announced Thursday morning that the Affordable Care Act, known to many as Obamacare, mandating every American to purchase health insurance is constitutional. How do you feel about the decision? Vote in our poll or share your thoughts in

The Supreme Court announced Thursday morning that the Affordable Care Act mandating every American to purchase health insurance is constitutional and should stand.

The court decided that the government is permitted to penalize individuals who refuse to purchase health insurance, according to NBC News. The Supreme Court ruled that the federal government can levy a "tax" on individuals who do not buy into the system, according to NBC News.

The individual health care mandate is the key provision in Obamacare, and some legal experts thought that it could be ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court. Had it been stripped from the law, many other provisions—such as covering people with pre-existing conditions and not capping insurance coverage—most likely would have been removed, as well.

The decision is a major victory for the Obama administration, which touted the law passed in March 2010 as its signature legislative achievement. However, there are other Americans who decried the law because of concerns about the federal government's role in regulating the health care industry.

The Supreme Court justices listened to oral arguments on the case in late March before issuing their decision at 10 a.m. Thursday. The court voted 5-4 to uphold the law with Chief Justice John Roberts casting the deciding vote and writing the majority opinion.

One of the few Democrats to vote against the health care law was U.S. Rep. Jason Altmire, D-McCandless. Today, he agreed with the high court's decision.

"I never believed, nor did I ever argue, that it would be found unconstitutional. I voted against the bill because my constituents were overwhelmingly against it, and because I believed that bill was flawed policy," he said.

"Now that the Court has ruled, it is my hope that we can once and for all put the acrimonious political debate behind us and do what we should have been doing all along—working together in a bipartisan fashion to improve upon the law and bring down health care cost for American families, businesses and the government."

U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, wants to repeal the law and find other solutions for the health care system.

“Congress must get to work on fully repealing this bill and undoing the new tax before it goes into full effect,” Murphy wrote in a statement. “The bill that was rushed through Congress and signed into law was unpopular, unworkable and unsustainable. It was not designed to deliver the kind of healthcare reforms Americans want and need. Simply put, a healthcare tax is not healthcare reform.”

U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-PA, maintained that the court made the wrong decision.

"I'm deeply disappointed that the U.S. Supreme Court has upheld Obamacare," he said in a statement posted on his Facebook page. "Today's ruling is a blow to personal liberties. It's up to Congress now to pass a full repeal."

Tommey's counterpart on the other side of the aisle admits the law is far from perfect.

"I will continue to work with other senators to make improvements to the legislation," said Sen. Bob Casey, D-PA. "Further, there is no doubt that we still confront significant challenges to reducing the cost of health care, and the only way to address these in the long run is for Democrats and Republicans to work together."

How do you feel about the Supreme Court’s decision to uphold Obamacare? Tell us in the comments section below.

proud American July 6, 2012 at 06:52 pm
Still don't believe that they will use any thing the average citizen uses they will find a way around it they have passed many laws on a late friday night session.
cc July 6, 2012 at 07:02 pm
What is going to happen when doctors opt out of working with insurance companies, medicare and medicaid (obamacare)? Most of these doctors owe hundreds of thousands back on student loans and they also have to purchase malpractice insurance because Americans love to file lawsuit and sue doctors.
cc July 6, 2012 at 07:37 pm
Totally agree with you Proud American. They won't be under obamacare with their healthcare, they get everything paid for but they stick this garbage down out throats.
Pat O'Neil July 6, 2012 at 08:38 pm
@Mike ... Actually, Mike is partially correct, but if you look at the link he provided you will see that the 3.8% is only applied if you make $200k + ($250,000k for couples) and doesn't apply to the first $250k (500k for couples) of profit from the sale. Makes you wonder though what else is buried in this bill.
Lou Pietosi July 6, 2012 at 09:22 pm
EVERYONE WANTS Universal Healthcare but the REALITY is WE DO NOT HAVE THE MONEY TO COVER AN ADDITIONAL 30 MILLION PEOPLE! In addition, it will be more like 50 million when about 20 million of us LOSE the private plans we now pay for becuause many employers will pay the TAX rather than offer the coverage knowing we can all sign up for the PUBLIC coverage-WHICH IS EXACTLY WHAT OBAMA WANTS!!!__HE WANTS ALL OF US DEPENDANT ON THE FEDERAL GOVT FOR EVERYTHING!!! People need to WAKE UP--FORGET THEIR PARTY AFFILIATION AND L E A R N WHAT THE HELL THIS IS REALLY ABOUT! I want Big Govt OUT OF MY LIFE NOT ALL OVER IT!
bd July 6, 2012 at 09:52 pm
Stacy - No. youe are not correct about Obama's executive order. It had NOTHING to do with a person born in this country from illegal immigrants. He did NOTHING to defend the Constitution. His executive order allows illegal immigrants to remain in this country which is counter to the the law of this land. Take a read: http://www.cnn.com/2012/06/15/politics/immigration/index.html
Jean Smith July 6, 2012 at 10:12 pm
Amen Lou, his obamacare is a bunch of hogwash with hidden taxes in there that people think is the best thing since sliced bread.
Jean Smith July 6, 2012 at 10:40 pm
Stacy- I am half French and half German and take no offense in what Outraged Citizen said about smelly people stinking, There are smelly people in all races and nationalities because some people don't believe in using deodorant. Have you never been on a bus or trolley going into Pittsburgh and your standing next to someone that didn't use deodorant.
Jean Smith July 6, 2012 at 10:53 pm
Stacy- Just having a drivers license does not require you to have the minimal auto insurance. You only need auto insurance if you own and operate a vehicle.. So comparing auto insurance to obamacare does not work at all. Many people have drivers license and pay no auto insurance because they don't have a car. Some people own cars and have no insurance and that is why we have uninsured motorist on our policies.
Jean Smith July 6, 2012 at 11:31 pm
Stacy-No way you can compare auto insurance to obamacare. Statistics say that up to 25% of Americans doesn't have auto insurance. That is why we all have to carry Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage on our insurance. It also depends if you live in a no-fault state or a state that uses Torte.
http://www.carinsurancecomparison.com/what-happens-when-you-get-into-a-car-accident-and-the-other-person-doesnt-have-insurance
Stacy July 6, 2012 at 11:33 pm
@bd,
From the article you cite:"Under the new policy, people younger than 30 who came to the United States before the age of 16, pose no criminal or security threat, and were successful students or served in the military can get a two-year deferral from deportation, Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano said." People born in this country are, according to our Constitution, American citizens. The only possible thing you must be upset about is if a child between the ages of 1-15 was brought here by their parents being allowed to stay legally. Sorry, but holding 8 years olds in contempt for the actions of their parents is not what I believe in.
Jean Smith July 6, 2012 at 11:53 pm
ML- you attack everyone that doesn't believe in your way of thinking, as you say that you are always correct. You make fun of people and have to point out that they spelled something wrong. Not everyone in this world is a perfect speller not do some make proper sentences but she has no right to make fun of them. She sometimes reads articles halfway and misses key areas of the article but then mocks you for something you said pertaining to the article that she didn't see or read.
Jean Smith July 7, 2012 at 12:58 am
Marsha I have to agree with you there, as there is also people that have had healthcare that never set their foot in a doctors office, had checkup, don't watch what they eat, don't exercise, smoke and end up going to the emergency room because of a heart attack or stroke, ends up having a triple bypass because they didn't take care of themselves. We also have people that go to the doctors and emergency rooms for a cold or a blister on their foot. Emergency rooms aren't meant for getting a checkup.
Jean Smith July 7, 2012 at 12:59 am
Stacy this is not true at all, Kaiser Permenante does not own Kaiser Policy Institute.
Jean Smith July 7, 2012 at 01:07 am
Why is Justme cruel because she said to send him back where he lived part of his life at. If the house and senate goes Republican, you don't think they would vote out obamacare? Plus he can use threatening tactic that obama used when he wanted this bill passed.
Jean Smith July 7, 2012 at 01:17 am
It was obamabinliar that filed suit against Arizona when they made it a law to ship illegals back to where they belong if they were found to be illegally in the United States. In California, they quit giving food stamps to Illegals and are just giving them to the children that were born in the United State along with Medicaid. The illegals now are fighting this, as they say how can I feed my family on 129 a month in foodstamps. Go back to your own country and have Mexico feed you and give you foodstamps. If an American goes to Mexico to live, they cannot get free food, free medical, free anything, but yet here we take care of Illegals better than they take care of our own.
Stacy July 7, 2012 at 12:42 pm
Jean,
Both Kaiser P. and Kaiser Fam. were stared by the same entity. With that fact I am stating that I think they are biased in their opinions to be supportive of each other. I understand you do not agree.
Stacy July 7, 2012 at 12:43 pm
*typo: "started" not "stared"
Erin Conners July 7, 2012 at 08:15 pm
The summary of the majority opinion went up.
http://cranberry.patch.com/blog_posts/supreme-court-ruling-on-the-individual-mandate-and-medicaid-expansion
b smith July 7, 2012 at 08:51 pm
By it being a RIGHT that means that all healthcare workers have become slaves to the rest of our countrymen. Since they are mandated to take care of you now regardless pf the amount they are being paidfor your stay. Everyone was already given healthcare on any hospital in the USA. No hospital will deny you care before this law was even on the books. People get mad cause doctors make money and live in big house but when did you go to college for 8 to 10 years and put in internships of working 24 hour shifts and then work 12 to 16 hour days sometime 6-7 days a week saving peoples lives. Sorry but sitting around gettring pregnant and just collecting your neighbors hard earned tax dollars for doing nothing doesn't seem valid for enslaving someone else.
Lou Pietosi July 7, 2012 at 09:09 pm
Let's be realistic here. The REAL tax rate isn't 35%~JUST the FEDERAL rate is. After taking 6 or 7% sales tax, state and local tax, gas tax, and real estate taxes, HOW MUCH MORE are we expected or even able to give? NO~ANY increase is wrong right now. How about this NOVEL IDEA: CUT FEDERAL SPENDING! The feds are spending money we DON'T have! They're borrowing more and more! A tax CUT stimulates the economy, adds jobs which actually ADD to tax revenues! Regean did it and our tax revenues saw a HUGE increase! Its simple~allow the FREE MARKETS to thrive rather than over regulate and strangle them!
And psmith~youre on a ROLL! Go go go! LOL
Lou Pietosi July 7, 2012 at 09:13 pm
Go back and READ what the founding Fathers WARNED us of: BIG GOVT! The feds are supposed to allow the states the ability to run themselves yet we have an administration hellbent on suing states rather than statying OUT of their way! My goodness you can't even ask for someone to prove their I'd when voting without a lawsuit! Its rediculous! rEAD what Jefferson and Franklin said!
Stacy July 8, 2012 at 03:02 am
@Lou: You are correct about our government spending money it doesn't have. Our debt doubled (yes, doubled) under GW Bush; under President Obama it has risen significantly as well, although 50% less than under Bush. The US has always carried debt. I agree with you that it has gotten out of control, I just wonder why no one seemed to notice that it doubled under GW. The Founding Fathers warned of many things and it would benefit us all to read more on that, including their views on protecting labor. I do not like the increases we have seen in taxes, and I am most against our waste in government programs as well as our constant war-mongering. I would much rather see us spend our dollars building up our own country, our own people, our own schools, and the health of our own people. I may come off more liberal than not in these posts simply because I am for affordable health care for all American citizens, but I am also for all of us being responsible. Debt rose significantly under Reagan (raising the national debt from $997 billion to $2.85 trillion) to the degree that even Reagan admitted it was the disappointment of his Presidency. I think we need more wise investment in our own people and absolutely I feel that politicians should not be allowed more than 2 terms. Wouldn't it be interesting if the American people were allowed to submit real input on the budget? I'll be some "average" Americans have some really good ideas on how we could trim up our budget.
Lou Pietosi July 10, 2012 at 09:52 pm
ML no drama intended. My point is that lets say you earn 50,000.and pay 30% in federal income tax. That leaves you with 35K. Then you pay 6% sales tax on much of what you buy during the year. Then you pay about a 55 cent per gallon tax on gas. Then you pay 1% to the local govt on top of real estate taxes of maybe 2500.00. Add your State tax to that and the taxes on all your utility bills, your cell phone bill, cable bill, etc. not to mention the excise taxes on those bills Regardless of deductions and MOST middle class families have very few deductions--how much MORE is expected of us as tax payers. The "effective" tax % taken out of OUR money is 40 to sometimes over 50% if you add all this up. THAT was the point I was making.
Thanks!
Lou Pietosi July 10, 2012 at 10:57 pm
Ha ha. It wa intentionally fuzzy~meaning all estimates. Use your own numbers. Take your actual incomr the start deducting ALL the different taxes you pay. I bet you're over 40% unless you have a lot of deductions. But you got my point that at the end of the long workweek its disheartening to only get to keep a little over 50 cents ~in some cases less~for every dollar you earned. Then on top of that deduct you healthcare cost and tell me if tyou think its fair we pay even MORE to insure 30 to 50 million more!
Isabella Valentine July 10, 2012 at 11:09 pm
ML, Lou's math isn't fuzzy at all.
Here are a couple articles on the topic. One is really wordy, the other simplistic; however, from 2005. I couldn't find a more current simple explanation. We don't have a tax problem in this country, we have a spending problem and we need to get it under control soon. If more people were successful like Romney, instead of takingn handouts from the governmemt, everyone would be able to keep more of the money they earn. I still can't believe I'm paying a monthly tax on my cell phone bill so the entitlement class can have a free Obama phone. When did a cell phone become a necessity. Some of you just don't get it. http://www.nowandfutures.com/taxes.html http://readersupportednews.org/pm-section/78-78/8114-how-much-do-we-really-pay-in-taxes http://obamaphone.net/
Outraged Citizen July 11, 2012 at 12:20 am
@ML – The reason is you are quite capable of defending yourself while the others you mention are not so fortunate. Secondly, I make no pretenses that I am a smug, snarky pseudo-intellectual. I own who I am with no apologies or expectations of others.
rob kamensky July 11, 2012 at 03:19 pm
people worry more about what mittens does with his money , when you should worried about what the government is doing with our money, who gives a crap what mittens or other folks do with theirs... worry more about the ones in office and sit behind fancy government desks!!
erika August 20, 2012 at 09:11 pm
@ Jean Smith:
You say: 4:06 pm on Thursday, June 28, 2012 Mike I know I pay with my taxes for illegals and people on welfare and don't want to work for them to go to emergency rooms. I have been checking out prices of insurance under obama care and i'm going to be paying $432 a month for heath care for my son and I. You tell me how that is cheap health care since I have RSD and Fibromyalgia. I pay now 298 for a neurologist and medications a month. I'll stick with paying doctors and for my prescriptions myself" So who pays for you when you have an emergency due to an act of god or just because you have preexisting conditions that render you fairly unhealthy? If you don't have insurance? The taxpayers, that's who.
Jean Smith August 21, 2012 at 12:43 am
erika - sorry but it isn't the tax payers that pays for me to go to the emergency room if I need treated. I pay for all my own medical bills. First off, If I need to be seen by a doctor, I go to a MedPlus down on Rt 51 and so far they have been able to treat me when I am sick. and never had to go to an emergency room. Then when they send me the bill, I make a payment out of my own money and not the tax payers. I also started a bank account back in 1994 that I put $375 a month in for medical purposes only. In the 17 years that I have had this account, I have saved over $75,000 for Medical Purposes only. Thank goodness I have never had to touch the money other than to pay for MedPlus and for co-payments for my son for when he is sick.
So Erica don't tell me that it is the tax payers that pay for my medical treatments, I know how to save money for what I need. I also work full time and own 12 homes in Whitehall which I paid all of them off. I save money and don't waste it as you do and don't want obamacare. I want Romney as President so that I don't get stuck with paying for your medical insurance since you must be one that runs to emergency rooms every time you break a nail or get a little cold.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Chartiers Valley Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Jane Sorcan June 6, 2013 at 01:18 pm
Ronda, thanks for helping spread the word that I am available to help residents reduce energy costs.Read More I will be at the Scott Twp. Safety Fair being held in Scott Park from 10a-2p on Sat., June 8th. Jane
Alacunya May 28, 2013 at 10:28 pm
Thank you Carol R. for your tireless efforts in helping to raise awareness of this disease. YourRead More efforts will not go unnoticed. I will be there to walk with you on Saturday